top of page

Why North Korea Is Considered a Totalitarian Dictatorship: Looking Beyond the Constitution

reagangrecco
Jul 28
6 min read

One of the most common arguments made in defense of North Korea is that its constitution guarantees rights. Supporters often point to provisions regarding education, healthcare, employment, religious freedom, or elections as evidence that the country is not a dictatorship. At first glance, these arguments may seem convincing. After all, if a constitution guarantees rights, shouldn’t those rights exist?



Comparative politics suggests otherwise.

Political scientists rarely classify governments based solely on what is written in their constitutions. Instead, they examine whether institutions actually function as they are intended to. This distinction between de jure (on paper) and de facto (in practice) governance is one of the most important concepts in comparative politics.


A constitution may promise democratic institutions, but if those institutions cannot independently constrain political power, the constitution functions more as a statement of ideology than a limitation on government authority.


North Korea illustrates this distinction better than almost any other country.


Why Political Scientists Classify Governments by Institutions, Not Labels

One of the biggest misconceptions in political discourse is the belief that governments should be judged by what they call themselves or what their constitutions promise. In comparative politics, that is not how political systems are classified.

Instead, political scientists study institutions in practice.


This distinction is often described as the difference between de jure institutions and de facto institutions.


De jure institutions are the formal rules written into constitutions and laws. They describe how a government is supposed to operate.

De facto institutions are how power actually functions in reality. They examine who makes decisions, whether courts can act independently, whether elections are genuinely competitive, whether opposition parties can realistically win office, and whether constitutional rights can be enforced against the government itself.


This distinction matters because many authoritarian governments maintain constitutions that resemble those of democratic states. They may establish legislatures, courts, elections, and guarantee freedoms such as speech, religion, or assembly. However, if those institutions operate under the control of a ruling party or political leader rather than independently, their existence on paper tells us very little about how political power is actually exercised.


North Korea provides one of the clearest examples of this principle.

Its constitution outlines governmental institutions and recognizes numerous rights, but comparative politics asks a different question: Can those institutions independently limit the government’s power?

The overwhelming consensus among scholars is that they cannot.


Patricia Goedde argues that North Korea’s constitution should not simply be dismissed as meaningless. Rather, it serves important political functions by reinforcing state ideology, legitimizing the regime, and organizing the structure of government. At the same time, its constitutional provisions do not operate as independent constraints on executive authority in the way constitutions typically do within constitutional democracies.


This is why comparative politics focuses on observable political behavior rather than constitutional language. Scholars classify regimes by examining how institutions function in practice—not by accepting governments’ official descriptions of themselves.

Understanding this distinction is essential before asking whether North Korea is a dictatorship. The question is not whether democratic institutions exist on paper. The question is whether they possess the independence necessary to exercise meaningful political authority. According to decades of comparative politics research, North Korea’s institutions remain subordinate to the ruling leadership, making the practical distribution of power fundamentally different from what its constitutional text alone might suggest.


What Is a Dictatorship?

A dictatorship is a political system in which political power is concentrated in the hands of one leader or a small ruling elite while meaningful political competition is absent. Elections may exist, legislatures may meet, and constitutions may guarantee rights, but these institutions do not independently determine political outcomes.


Instead, the government controls the mechanisms that would normally hold leaders accountable.


Ronald Wintrobe argues that North Korea should be understood as a military dictatorship because political survival depends heavily on military institutions and centralized coercive power. While ideology certainly plays an important role, military authority remains one of the regime’s primary tools for maintaining political control.


Similarly, Wonjun Song and Joseph Wright place North Korea within the broader study of authoritarian regimes by comparing its institutional structure with other autocracies. Rather than treating North Korea as an anomaly, they argue that it shares many defining characteristics found across highly centralized dictatorships while also possessing unique hereditary features.


Taken together, these studies reinforce an important point: political scientists classify North Korea based on how power is exercised, not on the language contained within its constitution.


Dictatorship vs. Totalitarianism

Although these terms are often used interchangeably, they describe different aspects of political power.


A dictatorship explains who holds power.

Totalitarianism explains how that power is exercised.


A totalitarian regime seeks to control not only political institutions but nearly every aspect of public life. This includes education, media, political participation, economic organization, culture, information, and ideology. The objective is not simply to eliminate opposition but to shape society itself.


North Korea fits this definition because political authority extends well beyond government offices. State ideology permeates schools, media, public ceremonies, and everyday political life. Political loyalty is not simply expected—it becomes integrated into social identity.


As Alzo David-West argues in North Korea and the Contradiction of Inversion, North Korea presents itself internationally as a socialist, anti-imperialist republic while simultaneously maintaining one of the world’s most centralized systems of hereditary political authority. He describes this contradiction as an inversion: institutions and official rhetoric often project one image while political practice reveals another. In other words, the state’s constitutional and ideological claims cannot be understood without examining how political power actually functions.


The Constitution Exists—but Institutions Matter More

One misconception surrounding North Korea is that its constitution disproves claims of dictatorship.

In reality, political scientists do not assume that constitutions automatically reflect how governments operate.


Patricia Goedde argues that dismissing North Korea’s constitution as merely “fake” overlooks its actual political function. Rather than serving primarily as a legal restraint on government power, the constitution reinforces ideological legitimacy, organizes state institutions, and communicates the state’s governing philosophy.


This distinction is critical.


A constitution can guarantee freedom of speech while independent media remain absent.

It can establish elections while eliminating meaningful political competition.

It can promise judicial protections while courts remain subordinate to political leadership.

It can outline a legislature while that legislature lacks the ability to independently challenge executive authority.


The question is not whether rights appear in constitutional language. The question is whether institutions possess enough independence to enforce those rights against the government itself.

Comparative politics focuses on institutional behavior, not constitutional promises.


Elite Politics Reveal How Power Actually Operates

One way political scientists evaluate authoritarian systems is by studying elite politics.


In democracies, leadership changes through competitive elections.


In dictatorships, leadership survival depends on maintaining support from key political elites, military officials, and ruling party members.

Paasha Mahdavi and John Ishiyama examine these dynamics inside North Korea’s ruling elite. Their research demonstrates that promotions, appointments, and elite turnover are carefully managed to preserve regime stability. Rather than relying on electoral accountability, leadership maintains power through the continued loyalty of influential political and military elites.


This pattern reflects a defining characteristic of authoritarian governance: political survival depends primarily on elite cohesion rather than electoral competition.


North Korea and Russia: Similar, but Not the Same

Comparing North Korea with Russia demonstrates that authoritarian governments exist along a spectrum.

Russia is generally classified as a competitive authoritarian or electoral authoritarian regime. Elections occur, opposition parties formally exist, and some political competition remains, although significant institutional advantages favor the incumbent government.

North Korea operates under a much more centralized political system.


Political competition is effectively nonexistent.

Leadership has remained within the Kim family for three generations.

Independent media do not function as a meaningful institutional check on government authority.


Political ideology is embedded throughout education, media, and public life.

While both governments centralize power, North Korea represents a significantly greater degree of political and social control. Comparative politics therefore places North Korea much closer to the totalitarian end of the authoritarian spectrum.


This comparison also highlights why comparative politics avoids treating all dictatorships as identical. Authoritarian regimes vary in the extent to which they permit political competition, tolerate dissent, and allow independent institutions to function. North Korea remains one of the clearest examples of a regime where virtually every major institution ultimately answers to the ruling leadership.


Conclusion

The existence of a constitution does not determine whether a country is democratic.

What matters is whether institutions operate independently enough to constrain political power.


Across decades of comparative politics research, scholars consistently classify North Korea as a dictatorship because political authority remains concentrated within a hereditary ruling system where meaningful political competition, independent institutional oversight, and effective constitutional constraints are absent.


Its constitution remains politically important—but primarily as a source of legitimacy and ideological organization rather than as an independent safeguard of constitutional rights.

When viewed through the lens of comparative politics instead of constitutional text alone, North Korea fits the defining characteristics of a totalitarian dictatorship. Its institutions, elite dynamics, concentration of power, and mechanisms of social control align closely with the characteristics identified by scholars studying authoritarian regimes across the world. Looking beyond constitutional language and examining how political power operates in practice explains why the overwhelming consensus within comparative politics classifies North Korea as one of the world’s most enduring totalitarian dictatorships.


References


David-West, A. North Korea and the Contradiction of Inversion: Dictatorship, Markets, Social Reform.


Goedde, P. (2020). Beyond Sham: The North Korean Constitution. Asian Perspective, 44(1), 1–29.


Mahdavi, P., & Ishiyama, J. Dynamics of the Inner Elite in Dictatorships: Evidence from North Korea.


Song, W., & Wright, J. The North Korean Autocracy in Comparative Perspective.

Wintrobe, R. North Korea as a Military Dictatorship.

 
 
 

Comments


bottom of page